About Olmo
Olmo serves the kind of bagel-focused menu that draws locals and visitors back for repeat visits.
Reviews praise a light, chewy bagel texture and a rotating set of nontraditional schmears — from beet and dill to spicy scallion — paired with bold options like za’atar and chili crisp oil.
Service and hospitality are recurring themes: staff are described as helpful and friendly, the operation moves quickly even when busy, and there’s a mix of kiosk and cashier ordering that keeps turnover steady.
Catering and to-go orders are also part of the offering.
Location & Contact
- Address93 Whitney Ave, New Haven, CT 06510
- Websitehttps://olmobagels.com
- Phone(203) 624-3373
- Links Get directions
What to Expect
The menu centers on expertly made bagels and creative spreads.
Reviewers highlight the Everything Everything, Za’atar, Cacio e Pepe and a standout chili crisp oil bagel, plus classics like lox and bacon, egg & cheese.
House schmears — beet & veggie, scallion, and coconut — get frequent praise for flavor and balance.
Sides and specials also get noticed: potato latkes are described as peppered and satisfying, okonomiyaki appears on previews, and baked goods like babka and muffins round out a breakfast-and-lunch roster that favors freshness and bold seasoning.
Hashtag Breakfast Fact's
The Influence of Immigrant Flavors
Immigrant communities have significantly shaped Connecticut's breakfast landscape. The arrival of diverse cultures brought new flavors and dishes, enriching the morning meal. From Italian frittatas to Latino breakfast burritos, the infusion of various cuisines has made breakfast an exciting culinary adventure. This blending of flavors reflects the state’s multicultural identity, making each breakfast experience a celebration of heritage. As people explore these diverse options, they not only get a taste of different cultures but also foster a greater understanding and appreciation of one another.
Menu Highlights
From the Community
On Whitney Avenue, Olmo has become a go-to for people looking for bagels that bend tradition without losing quality.
The shop earns consistent praise for dough that’s fresh and chewy, inventive spreads and sandwiches that don’t hold back on seasoning.
Lines are common, but a mix of touchscreen ordering and attentive staff keeps things moving.
Menu favorites show up repeatedly in reviews: the Everything Everything bagel, za’atar paired with spicy scallion schmear, a cacio e pepe option and a chili crisp oil bagel that several visitors singled out.
Catering and packaged orders also factor into the operation; one reviewer noted Olmo catered a wedding breakfast with "top notch food."
Hospitality is a through-line: customers describe staff as welcoming and helpful, often offering samples or quick suggestions.
As one fan put it, "Everything everything bagel is a must" (Julianna Renee), while another said, "Their schmear is to die for" (Vivek Patel).
Minor notes include occasional temperature issues when items marked "toasted" arrived cool, but overall the mix of inventive flavors, reliable technique and warm service keeps people coming back.
Why Locals Love It
Customer Reviews
"Outdoor seating only. Inside there are computers to order on or a cashier at one in the back. Great service and very efficient. Bagels are delicious, unique flavors and great quality on classics. Willing to make adjustments to order if go to cashier. Everyone is very friendly and welcoming. 10/10 would recommend if you visit new haven area. Everything everything bagel is a must, okonomiyaki and lox with love are my go to whenever I visit, but the hot turkey has become a new favourite for a hungry higher protein meal."
"Finally got to try Olmo’s and I can definitely say why it’s rated the best bagel shop in New Haven. I ordered the Za’atar bagel with spicy scallion cream cheese, which I was coincidentally told was one of the most popular combos. Needless to say the flavor is excellent and the cream cheese didn’t skimp on the spices. Great service too - even during a rush they managed to keep things running smooth and lighthearted, and I really appreciated the friendliness of the cashier Megan!"
"Hands down the best bagel shop in New Haven! Their schmear is to die for, and the chili crisp oil bagel really stands out—so flavorful. It was my first visit, and despite being busy, the gentleman working there took the time to help me with a recommendation—and it definitely worked for me. I took home a variety of bagels for my family, and we loved every single one. Amazing service and even better food. Can’t wait to go back!"
"Olmo is our go to bagel place in New Haven, great bagels, friendly staff and conveniently located on the corner of Whitney and Trumbull. Because they have such a great product, there’s almost a guaranteed wait. Order ahead and you’re smooth sailing, but if you’re in a rush and plan to walk-in you may be waiting a while (from my own experience it’s ~10-15 minutes). Good variety of bagels, sandwiches and accoutrements, and non-typical schmears, all in all- worth trying!"
Hashtag Breakfast Fact's
Modern Breakfast Innovations
The modern breakfast landscape is constantly evolving, driven by creativity and innovation. In Connecticut, chefs and home cooks alike experiment with ingredients and cooking methods, leading to exciting new dishes. From avocado toast to artisanal pastries, breakfast menus now cater to a variety of tastes and dietary needs. This trend encourages people to think outside the box and embrace the art of breakfast, transforming it into an experience rather than just a meal. The willingness to explore and innovate reflects the dynamic nature of food culture today.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes Olmo’s bagels different from other bagels?
Their bagels are often described as fresh, light and chewy with a nice bounce. Reviews say the dough is made to hold up to hearty fillings, so sandwiches feel balanced and not soggy.
Do they have unique cream cheese flavors?
Yes. Customers mention inventive schmears like beet & veggie, scallion, coconut and spicy scallion. These spreads are flavorful and often paired with specific bagels to enhance the sandwich.
Which bagels do people recommend?
Popular picks include the Everything Everything, Za’atar, Cacio e Pepe and a chili crisp oil bagel. Reviewers often name the Everything Everything as a must-try and praise the za’atar with spicy scallion schmear.
How are the latkes and sides described?
The potato latke is compared to a flavored potato hash — peppered and satisfying. It’s treated like a proper savory side, not just a tiny garnish.
Are there vegan or plant-forward options?
Menu previews list a Poppy Bagel Sandwich Vegan. Reviews also praise vegetable-forward schmears like beet & veggie, so there are plant-focused choices to try.
Do they serve lox and classic bagel combos?
Yes. Lox is on the menu and reviewers mention classic bagel-and-smear options like lox and cream cheese as part of the lineup of savory choices.
What should I know about toasted bagels?
Some guests asked for toasted bagels; one review noted a toasted bagel arrived cool. That means toasting is offered, but temperature can vary depending on timing and service pace.
Is the za’atar bagel spicy or mild?
Za’atar itself is herb-forward and earthy rather than hot. Reviewers recommend pairing it with a spicy scallion schmear for a noticeable kick, so the spice level depends on the spread you choose.
Why do locals recommend Olmo in New Haven?
Locals praise Olmo for consistent dough, inventive schmears and warm service. The shop’s combination of bold flavors and hospitality has made it a neighborhood favorite in New Haven.
What pizzas are most popular at Olmo?
From the menu, people often pick Olmo Bagel, Lox Bagel, Iced Coffee, Feta, Babka, Okonomiyaki. Reviews highlight consistency more than novelty, so these are safe, crowd-pleasing choices.
Coffee: The Breakfast Companion
No discussion of breakfast would be complete without mentioning coffee, a beloved companion to morning meals. In Connecticut, coffee culture has flourished, becoming an integral part of the breakfast routine. Whether it's a quick cup on the go or a leisurely sip at the breakfast table, coffee has a way of bringing people together. The rise of specialty coffee shops and artisanal brews reflects a growing appreciation for quality, making the morning brew not just a beverage but a cherished ritual. This love for coffee enhances the overall breakfast experience, tying it to social interactions and daily calming moments.
Ad Placeholder
Connecticut's Premier Pizza Destinations
Current location in red, 8 nearest in blue, all others in gray
Olmo
Breakfast: A Curtain Raiser for the Day
For many, breakfast is more than just a meal; it sets the tone for the day ahead. In Connecticut, the morning ritual often includes a moment of mindfulness, where individuals gather their thoughts over their favorite foods. This practice can be especially grounding during busy weekdays. Whether it’s a simple bowl of cereal or an elaborate spread, the act of enjoying breakfast can be a comforting way to start the day. As morning routines evolve, many continue to find solace in this timeless tradition, reminding us of the importance of nurturing ourselves before stepping into the world.
Ad Placeholder
Explore Nearby Restaurants
Click any restaurant to view details
Poppy's Coffee and Kitchen
New Haven
0.6 miles away
Patricia's Restaurant
New Haven
0.6 miles away
Pantry
New Haven
0.7 miles away
The Farm Belly
New Haven
1.7 miles away
Barbara's Restaurant
Hamden
2.0 miles away
Bella's Cafe
New Haven
2.2 miles away
Georgie's Diner
West Haven
3.3 miles away
Nick's Luncheonette
West Haven
3.6 miles away
Breakfast Traditions Through Time
Breakfast has come a long way from its humble beginnings. In colonial America, the first meal of the day usually consisted of simple porridge or cornmeal, often paired with a hearty cider. As the nation grew and changed, so did breakfast. By the 19th century, the trend shifted towards more elaborate meals. Affluent society members began to indulge in lavish breakfasts that included eggs, bacon, and even pastries. In Connecticut, these evolving traditions mirrored the broader American experience, showcasing how breakfast has continuously adapted to reflect cultural shifts and local ingredients.
Ad Placeholder